Further call for VINLEC to abolish the fuel surcharge and update pricing model for electricity 

A One News SVG image showing VINLEC’s power plant at Lowmans Bay.

The views expressed herein are solely those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of One News SVG.

Further call for VINLEC to abolish the fuel surcharge and update pricing model for electricity 

By Luke Browne 

I would like to take this opportunity to reiterate my call for the abolition of VINLEC’s fuel surcharge and an update of its pricing model for electricity. I believe that this action would be in the national interest. In recent times, the surcharge reached record levels and we continue to operate under an outmoded and irrational pricing model for electricity. Needless to say, this matter has implications for the cost of living in our country.

Our electricity bills have 2 components – a basic charge and a fuel surcharge. 

The basic charge takes into account the price of diesel as it was all the way back in 1973 ($0.52 per gallon) and some other factors relevant to the supply of electricity. The fuel surcharge covers the difference between the price of fuel in the base year and the actual cost of fuel in the relevant month.

If for argument sake VINLEC uses 1,000 gallons of fuel which cost $10.52 per gallon in the course of producing 20,000 units of electricity during a particular month, the total fuel bill will be $10,520.00 for the month. The customers will pay $520.00 of this fuel bill under the basic charge and $10,000.00 of it under the fuel surcharge which will be $0.50 per unit of electricity.  

Why do we have a basic charge that is based on the price of diesel all the way back in 1973? We need to update it! 

We basically have a situation where VINLEC changes the price of electricity every month. This is both unnecessary and unacceptable. If van drivers can’t change their fares every time there is a change in the price of fuel, why must VINLEC be able to do it? We need to keep in mind that electricity is an essential service that is a provided by a publicly-owned monopoly and that there is therefore a far stronger case for regulating electricity prices than bus fares. 

Why should someone possibly have to pay more for electricity for a month during which they actually consumed less units of it as compared to previous months?  

VINLEC said that it does not “profit” from either the fuel surcharge or the price of fuel. In response to this statement, I would simply like to make the following points – 

• VINLEC’s pricing model incorporates a component of the fuel cost built into the basic rate and the model was clearly calibrated in such a way as to ensure that the company can generate a durable profit throughout the ages that is insulated from adverse movements in fuel costs. 

• Why can’t VINLEC as a publicly-owned company also give priority to protecting its customers against global price shocks?  

The fact that VINLEC could simply pass on fuel price increases to customers serves as a disincentive for innovation with respect to efficiency and renewable energy.

If VINLEC in a hypothetical scenario produces all the electricity required for a month from only renewable sources and therefore uses no diesel, the fuel surcharge will be zero. However, the customer will still have to pay the fuel component built into the basic charge.  

VINLEC’s pricing mechanism behaves as if there is no cost or cost variation associated with the production of renewable energy. Furthermore, it makes no distinction as to the various types of renewable energy.  

We can abolish the fuel surcharge, update the basic charge to reflect recent fuel prices and incorporate any other desirable adjustments and we can set a fixed price for electricity that is subject to periodic review. This would amount to a simplification and rationalisation of pricing for electricity.

END

Leave a Reply